In the tapestry of early modern Scottish witch trials, the case of Annabell Stewart provides a poignant glimpse into the fear and social dynamics of the period. As a 14-year-old residing in Pollokshaws, Paisley, Annabell, the daughter of Jonet Mathie, found herself entangled in the witchcraft hysteria that gripped Renfrewshire in the late 17th century. Accused of maleficium, or practicing harmful magic, and attending witches' meetings, her youth did little to shield her from the grim procedures of the time. Records indicate an initial confession, given on the 7th of January, 1677, within the confines of the local tolbooth, followed by a further confession later that month.
The trial of Annabell took place on the 14th of February, 1677, in Renfrew. Despite her age, the court found her guilty of the charges leveled against her. However, mindful of her underage status and perhaps swayed by prevailing concerns over their legal jurisdiction when it came to child defendants, the presiding judge ultimately commuted her sentence. This decision diverged from the typical outcome of such trials, which often ended in execution. Instead of facing the grim fate commonly meted out to those accused, Annabell was transferred to Glasgow. There, she was to receive spiritual guidance from ministers, reflecting an approach that sought correction and redemption, at least in part due to her tender age.