In the early 17th century, amidst the turmoil of witchcraft accusations that swept across Scotland, Robert Erskine of Logie found himself entangled in a series of grave charges that ultimately sealed his fate. A man of upper socioeconomic standing, Robert, who had the legacy of Johnne of Logy and was the heir apparent of Dun, was an unexpected figure in the typical narrative of witch hunts. Born into a position of privilege, his status did not shield him from the wrath of his contemporaries when accusations of witchcraft were leveled against him, alongside more nefarious charges of poisoning.
On December 1, 1613, Robert's trial concluded with a verdict of guilty. Though witchcraft was among the charges, the records emphasize that his execution was primarily for the crime of poisoning. The trial, which was prosecuted by the Lord Advocate, featured an assize brimming with individuals of high status, reflecting the gravity of his case. While specific details of the trial proceedings remain elusive, the absence of a record in the High Court suggests that proceedings may have taken place in a different venue, yet with significant legal oversight.
Robert's confession recorded that year highlights the serious nature of the accusations against him. Furthermore, his connections to figures such as Johnne Kirk, George Kirk, Gilbert Campbell, and Jonet Irving, all identified as accomplices in other trials, paint a picture of a network potentially involved in broader illicit activities. Ultimately, Robert Erskine met his end at the Mercat Cross, executed by beheading—a grim testament to the severe penalties faced by those ensnared by accusations during this fraught period in Scottish history.