Katherine Kirktoun's ordeal began on a chilling note when, on December 4th, 1629, she was denounced by Alexander Hamilton, a self-professed warlock. This denunciation rooted her in a web of accusations and paranoia that had gripped Haddington and the surrounding regions during the height of Scotland's witch trials. Alexander Hamilton's proclamation carried significant weight, as being named by someone who confessed knowledge of witchcraft could swiftly lead to imprisonment and trial.
By February 7th, 1630, Katherine found herself behind bars in the tolbooth of Haddington, awaiting trial by assize. The presbytery records note that the local clergy, referred to as the "brethren," were ordered to attend the proceedings. This underscores the seriousness with which the community approached such cases, blending ecclesiastical and civil measures in addressing alleged witchcraft. The assize would determine her fate, relying heavily on both the testimonies presented and the prevailing societal belief in the existence and threat of witches.
Katherine's trial reflects the pervasive influence of prominent figures in the witch trials, as records indicate Alexander Hamilton's history of mentioning her in other trials. He referred to her as a "Known Witch," a label that, once affixed, was difficult to remove and fraught with dire consequences. Katherine's experience is emblematic of a period when fear and superstition often overshadowed reason, leaving many like her ensnared in a perilous struggle within the judicial and societal systems of the time.